How Criminal Convictions Affect Your UK ILR & Citizenship Application: 2024 Good Character Rules Explained

The Good Character Requirement Explained

When applying for Indefinite Leave to Remain (ILR) or British Citizenship, you must meet the "good character" requirement. This isn't just about criminal convictions — it covers a range of behaviours including dishonesty, immigration offences, and financial issues.

However, for most applicants, the main concern is: "Will my past conviction or court sentence affect my application?"

The answer depends on:

• The type and severity of the sentence
• When the offence occurred
• When you're applying
• Whether you're applying for ILR or citizenship

Major Changes in 2023: The New "Balance of Probabilities" Approach

In 2023, the Home Office significantly changed how they assess good character for non-custodial sentences. This is crucial to understand:

The Old Rules (Before 2023)

Under the previous guidance, specific waiting periods applied:

• Custodial sentence of 4+ years: Permanent bar from citizenship
• Custodial sentence of 12 months - 4 years: 15-year waiting period
• Custodial sentence under 12 months: 10-year waiting period
• Non-custodial sentence (community orders, fines, etc.): 3-year waiting period

This meant if you received a fine or community order, you had to wait 3 years from the date of conviction before applying.

The New Rules (2023 Onwards)

The 2023 guidance introduced a more flexible approach for non-custodial sentences:

• Custodial sentences: The fixed waiting periods still apply
• Non-custodial sentences: Now assessed on the "balance of probabilities"

This means caseworkers now have discretion to consider the full circumstances of your case, rather than applying a blanket 3-year waiting period.

What "Balance of Probabilities" Means for Your Application

Under the new approach, the caseworker asks: "Is it more likely than not that this person is of good character?"

They consider:

• Nature and seriousness of the offence — A minor traffic offence vs. fraud
• How long ago it occurred — Recent vs. years ago
• Pattern of behaviour — One-off incident vs. repeated offending
• Your behaviour since — Clean record, rehabilitation, positive contributions
• Circumstances of the offence — Mitigating factors

How Different Sentences Are Treated

Custodial Sentences (Prison)

These still have fixed waiting periods:

Sentence Length	Waiting Period
4+ years imprisonment	Permanent bar (citizenship only)
12 months - 4 years	15 years from end of sentence
Under 12 months	10 years from end of sentence

Non-Custodial Sentences

These include:

• Fines (including court fines for traffic offences)
• Community orders
• Suspended sentences
• Conditional discharges
• Driving bans
• Penalty points

Under the new rules: No fixed waiting period. Assessed case-by-case on balance of probabilities.

Traffic Offences: What You Need to Know

Traffic offences are among the most common concerns for ILR and citizenship applicants. Here's how they're typically viewed:

Minor Traffic Offences

Offences like:

• Speeding (SP codes)
• Using a phone while driving (CU80)
• Driving without due care and attention (CD10, CD20, CD30)
• Minor documentation offences

If these result only in points and a fine (no prison sentence), they're considered non-custodial and assessed on balance of probabilities.

Serious Driving Offences

Offences like:

• Drink driving (DR10, DR20, DR30)
• Dangerous driving (DD40, DD60)
• Causing death by dangerous driving

These may result in custodial sentences, which carry fixed waiting periods. Even without prison time, they're viewed more seriously.

Real Scenario: CD20 Offence with Fine and Points

Let's address a common situation:

"I received a CD20 conviction (driving without due care and attention) with 5 penalty points and approximately £500 fine. The offence was in July 2023, sentence in January 2024. This is my only court sentence ever and my only fine in the past 5 years. I submitted my ILR application 2 weeks ago. Should I withdraw before biometrics and wait a year?"

Analysis

Type of sentence: Non-custodial (fine + points only)

Under old rules: Would need to wait 3 years from January 2024, meaning earliest application would be January 2027.

Under new rules: Assessed on balance of probabilities. No mandatory waiting period.

Factors in Your Favour

• ✅ Single offence — No pattern of criminality
• ✅ Minor nature — CD20 is a relatively minor driving offence
• ✅ No other convictions — Clean record otherwise
• ✅ No other fines in 5 years — Demonstrates generally law-abiding behaviour
• ✅ Non-custodial sentence — Falls under the new flexible assessment

Factors to Consider

• ⚠️ Recent offence — Less than 2 years ago
• ⚠️ Timing — Conviction was after the new rules came in, so caseworker has full discretion

Should You Withdraw?

This is a personal decision, but here are the considerations:

Arguments for proceeding:

• Under the new rules, there's no mandatory waiting period for non-custodial sentences
• A single minor traffic offence with no other history is unlikely to result in refusal on good character grounds
• The caseworker can exercise discretion in your favour
• You'll lose the application fee if you withdraw

Arguments for withdrawing:

• Waiting another year would put more distance between you and the offence
• Reduces any risk, however small
• If refused, it may complicate future applications

Our view: For a single CD20 offence with fine and points, where this is your only conviction ever and no other fines in 5 years, most immigration practitioners would consider this a low-risk application under the new rules. However, there's always some discretion involved, and only you can decide your risk tolerance.

What to Include in Your Application

If you proceed with your application despite having a conviction, you must disclose it. Here's how to present it:

1. Full Disclosure

Declare the conviction fully and accurately in your application form. Include:

• Date of offence
• Date of conviction/sentence
• Court name
• Offence details
• Sentence received

2. Supporting Letter

Consider including a brief letter explaining:

• The circumstances of the offence
• That it was an isolated incident
• Your clean record before and since
• Your contributions to UK society

3. Evidence of Good Character

Optional but helpful:

• Character references from employers, community members
• Evidence of community involvement
• Employment history showing stability

ILR vs Citizenship: Are the Rules Different?

Importantly, the good character requirements differ slightly:

ILR (Indefinite Leave to Remain)

• Good character is considered but there's no statutory requirement
• Generally more flexible than citizenship
• Caseworkers have broad discretion

British Citizenship (Naturalisation)

• Statutory requirement under the British Nationality Act 1981
• Stricter interpretation
• The fixed waiting periods for custodial sentences are mandatory

Key point: A conviction that doesn't prevent ILR may still require waiting for citizenship. Plan accordingly.

What If You're Refused on Good Character Grounds?

If your application is refused:

For ILR

• You may be able to request an administrative review if there was a case working error
• You can reapply with additional evidence or after more time has passed
• Your existing leave to remain isn't affected

For Citizenship

• You can reapply after addressing the issues raised
• There's no formal appeal, but you can challenge via judicial review in limited circumstances
• Your ILR isn't affected

Common Mistakes to Avoid

1. Failing to Disclose

Never hide a conviction. Non-disclosure is itself a ground for refusal and can be treated as deception. The Home Office can access criminal records.

2. Providing Inaccurate Information

Double-check dates, court names, and offence descriptions. Inconsistencies raise red flags.

3. Applying During Pending Proceedings

If you have pending criminal charges, wait until they're resolved. Applying while under investigation or awaiting trial is risky.

4. Ignoring Court Fines

Unpaid court fines can affect your application. Ensure all fines are paid before applying.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need to declare spent convictions?

Yes, for immigration purposes. The Rehabilitation of Offenders Act doesn't apply to immigration applications. You must declare all convictions, even spent ones.

What about fixed penalty notices (FPNs)?

Fixed penalty notices (like parking tickets or speeding tickets paid out of court) are generally not considered criminal convictions. However, if you went to court and were convicted, that's different.

Will penalty points alone affect my application?

If you received points through a fixed penalty notice (no court appearance), this typically isn't an issue. If points were imposed by a court as part of a conviction, you should declare the conviction.

How far back do I need to disclose?

You should disclose your entire criminal history, regardless of how long ago offences occurred.

Can I get legal advice on my specific case?

Yes, and we recommend it for complex situations. An immigration solicitor can review your specific circumstances and advise on timing and presentation of your application.

Key Takeaways

• 2023 rule change: Non-custodial sentences are now assessed on balance of probabilities, not a fixed 3-year wait
• Minor traffic offences: A single CD20 with fine and points is unlikely to result in refusal if it's your only conviction
• Always disclose: Never hide convictions — non-disclosure is worse than the conviction itself
• Present well: Include a covering letter explaining the circumstances and your clean record
• Risk assessment: Only you can decide whether to proceed or wait; consider your risk tolerance and circumstances

Related Reading

• UK ILR for Dependants: Complete Document Checklist
• Which UK Visa Types Count Toward ILR?
• UK Visa Administrative Review: Processing Times Guide

Official Government Resources

For official guidance on good character requirements, refer to these UK government pages:

• 🔗 Good Character: Nationality Policy Guidance — gov.uk
• 🔗 Criminality Guidance — gov.uk
• 🔗 Apply for Citizenship — gov.uk
• 🔗 Indefinite Leave to Remain — gov.uk
• 🔗 Naturalisation Application (Form AN) — gov.uk

Need Help With Your Application?

Navigating good character requirements can be stressful, especially with a conviction on your record. While we can't provide legal advice on specific cases, our Expert Review (£49) service can help ensure your documents are complete and properly presented.

For specific advice on how your conviction may affect your application, we recommend consulting with a qualified immigration solicitor who can assess your individual circumstances.

---